Seeing is Believing: A Real Access Control Flaw in Action

 You know, I've been talking about access control for a while now, but I really wanted to show you what this actually looks like in practice. Because let's be honest - sometimes you need to see something with your own eyes to really get it.

I was looking around online and found this perfect video that shows exactly the kind of access control mess-up we've been discussing.


Here's what's actually happening in this demo:


So the person in this video is using this practice website called OWASP Juice Shop - it's basically a digital training ground where security people can test out different hacking techniques without breaking any real laws.

Watch what happens: they log in as a normal user, go to their profile page, and then... this is the crazy part... they just change a number in the web address. Like, from "user?id=123" to "user?id=124". And just like that, they're looking at some other person's private information!


Why this freaks me out a bit:

This isn't some complicated hacking magic - it's literally just typing a different number. But it shows how the website completely failed to check: "Hey, are you actually allowed to see this other person's stuff?" 

It reminds me of those hotel key cards that accidentally work on every door. You're supposed to only get into your room, but instead you can wander into anyone's room.


What a better system would do:

A properly built website would have stopped and asked: "Wait, who are you again? And why do you think you should see this data?" And when it didn't like the answers, it would have shown an error page instead of spilling everyone's secrets.

Watching this demo really made me realize that access control isn't just some boring technical concept - it's the difference between keeping people's information safe and having it all out in the open.

Comments